Monday, April 2, 2012

Is it an OSHA Violation? That Depends . . . .

 THE OSHA TRAINING BLOG HAS MOVED TO OUR NEW WEBSITE. VISIT US AT https://oshatraining.com/osha-training-blogs/
 

15 comments:

  1. One thing you need to keep in mind. Some activities conducted by personnel in General Industry can be enforced under construction standards. The dividing line between construction and maintenance can be pretty doggone confusing. If in doubt, go with the toughest standard. Besides, in the case of the example used, a cage around a ladder isn't a fall protection device. It just directs the body so it's easier to find. That is, if the body doesn't get all tangled up in the cage and complicate the body retrieval.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Fall Protection trigger heights:
    General Industry 4 feet
    Construction 6 feet
    Steel erection 15 feet
    Controlled decking zones 30 feet
    Connectors (first man up) 30 feet

    ReplyDelete
  3. Oh yah and I forgot scaffolds which is 10 feet

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks for the clarification. It might be interesting to note that there are also specific regulations for one industry that are not discussed in the other, such as demolition and confined space. These do crossover into the other field also.

    ReplyDelete
  5. With aproximately 80% of falls over 8ft. resulting in a head injury or death Oregon, has chosen not to require fall protection below 10ft.in construction. In Cali it is 5ft. This creates even more confusion because states that have controll of thier Osha programs can differ greatly from state to state. My opion is that OSHA should go back to the federal government so that we all are on the same page when it come to OH&S. OROSHA has been told by the feds to strengthen its program for years and all Oregon does is drag its feet.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I remember a long time ago there was a disparity between 10 and 26 concerning regulating compressed air for cleaning. 1910 said <30psi and 1926 said it couldn't be greater than 30psi. It resulted in some of the air guns reading 29psi and others reading 30psi. It has since been alligned to both read <30psi.

    ReplyDelete
  7. An interpretive letter dated 11/18/03 explains OSHA's position on the differences between "Maintenance" and "Construction" activities. The letter is under 1910.12 (b). The footnotes in this letter are helpful

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Do you have a link? I have been trying to find that letter of interpretation every where.

      Thanks.

      Delete
    2. Try this one:

      http://www.osha.gov/pls/oshaweb/owadisp.show_document?p_table=INTERPRETATIONS&p_id=24789

      Thanks, Curtis

      Delete
  8. Just like on a Material Safety Data Sheet it often depends on which group is the most powerful in the manufacturer's company: research, sales and marketing, or the law department.

    My point: definately follow the manufacturer's recommendations as a minimum but ALSO apply good engineering judgement to apply stricter standards where appropriate to protect employees.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I have successfully used an employer's conformity to the specifications in general industry standards to show a reasonable level of care when fighting the more subjective construction standards. I agree with the commenter who said to generally comply with the tougher standard when there's a question whether GI or construction will apply. And remember, if they cite under the wrong sector's standard and have not amended the citation before trial (or charged in the alternative), a successful "jurisdictional" argument gets the citation vacated. I did this recently for a client in an electrical fatality case where they were cited under construction but the OSHA policy indicated that work on a secondary fault as they were doing was maintenance and under GI.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Gas cylinders on welding carts is another difference

    ReplyDelete
  11. Yes, fall protection on walking/working surfaces are different. Construction industry is 6 ft., while general industry is 4 ft.

    ReplyDelete
  12. It is important to know which standards apply. When dealing with asbestos, for example, the activity determines the standard. Folks that are normally classified as General Industry (1910) must comply with the Construction standards (1926) when performing activities defined as "construction" in 1926.1101 (Asbestos).

    ReplyDelete
  13. And how about the difference in 'protection from falling objects' requirements for toeboards. In GI it is 4" [1910.23(e)(4)] in Construction it is 3.5" [1926.503(j)(3)].

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for your comment. We review all comments for appropriate content and to filter out Spam, and post them as soon as possible.